Being named executor of an estate that includes a machine shop puts you in an unusual spot. You have a legal, fiduciary duty to get fair value for every asset in the estate, and that duty applies just as much to a CNC lathe as it does to a house or a bank account, even if you've never had to price a piece of industrial equipment in your life.
Here's what that responsibility actually involves, and how to meet it without becoming a machine tool expert overnight.
Why This Carries Real Responsibility
An executor who sells estate property for less than it's worth, or who can't show how a valuation was reached, can be held personally accountable to the beneficiaries. That's true for equipment just as much as real estate. The standard courts generally look for is fair market value, a documented, defensible number, not just whatever the first interested buyer offers.
The good news is that meeting this duty doesn't require you to understand CNC equipment yourself. It requires a credible process and a paper trail.
Fair market value is a specific standard
For estate and tax purposes, fair market value typically means what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller, neither under pressure, on the open market. That's a different number than a fast liquidation sale, and it's worth knowing which one applies to your situation before accepting an offer.
Need a documented number for the estate?
A free valuation gives you a real, explainable figure to include in your records.
Get My Free Equipment Valuation →What Meeting This Duty Actually Looks Like
1. Get an independent, documented valuation
A written valuation from a source with no stake in the outcome is the clearest way to demonstrate you acted in good faith, whether or not your state formally requires a certified appraisal for this asset class.
2. Understand fair market value versus liquidation value
These are genuinely different numbers. If you're valuing the estate for tax or inventory purposes, fair market value is usually the relevant standard. If the goal is simply to convert the equipment to cash, a liquidation sale may bring a different, often lower, number, and that's normal, not a sign anything went wrong.
3. Keep a clear paper trail of every step
Save the valuation, any offers you received, and your reasoning for the path you chose. This protects you if a beneficiary ever questions the outcome.
4. Coordinate timing with the estate attorney and beneficiaries
Some states restrict what an executor can sell before probate closes. Confirm this before moving equipment out the door, and keep beneficiaries reasonably informed to avoid disputes later.
What a Defensible Valuation Should Include
- Machine-by-machine detail. Brand, model, year, and condition for each significant piece, not a single lump estimate for the whole shop.
- The basis for the number. A brief explanation of how the figure was reached, comparable sales, market conditions, and condition assessment.
- A date. Estate valuations are often tied to a specific date, commonly the date of death, so timing matters.
- Contact information for whoever provided it. In case a question comes up later, from beneficiaries or a probate court.
What This Usually Looks Like
Early in administration
Inventory the equipment and confirm whether a formal appraisal is required in your state for this estate's size.
Getting the valuation
Obtain a documented, dated figure, ideally from an independent source.
Deciding how to proceed
Coordinate with the attorney on timing and any restrictions on selling before probate closes.
Completing the sale
Execute the sale and retain all documentation as part of the estate's final accounting.
FAQ
Am I personally liable if I sell equipment for less than it's worth?
Potentially, if you can't show you made a good faith effort to determine fair value. A documented valuation is your best protection.
What is "fair market value" for probate purposes?
Generally, what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller, with neither under pressure to act, as of a specific date, often the date of death.
Do I need a certified appraiser or is a valuation from a buyer enough?
Requirements vary by state and estate size. A written, dated, well-reasoned valuation is the key factor either way, ask your estate attorney what your specific situation requires.
What if beneficiaries disagree with how the equipment was valued or sold?
Clear documentation is what resolves this in almost every case. It's much easier to defend a decision you documented at the time than to reconstruct your reasoning later.
Get a documented number you can stand behind
A free, no obligation valuation gives you a clear figure and reasoning for the estate's records.
Start My Free Valuation →